Conservatives get less than half the votes but two-thirds of councillors in elections

SA Updated
Conservatives get less than half the votes but two-thirds of councillors in elections

The Conservative Party has taken two-thirds of the Devon County Council seats in the South Hams, despite winning less than half of the votes. 

We have had a look at the data that came out of the Devon County Council elections in the South Hams and the results are interesting, mainly due to our First Past The Post system of voting. 

In the South Hams, more people voted for parties other than the Conservative Party, and yet the Conservatives won four out of the seven seats. The Liberal Democrats won two with 24% and the Green party won one with nearly 14%. The Labour Party took 13% of the votes, but won no seats. 

 

Across the seven seats, the results were as follows:

Conservative -                          14,287 (46.8%)

Liberal Democrat -                      7,332 (24%)

Green -                                     4,180 (13.7%)

Labour -                                    3,922 (12.8%)

Freedom Alliance -                        648 (2.12%)

Reform UK -                                   92 (0.3%)

Trade Union and Socialist Coalition - 82 (0.27%)

 

This means that when the South Hams voted, it looked like this: 

But what we all got was this: 

This is due to the fact that in this country, we use the First Past the Post system, rather than Proportional Representation, which is used by 40/43 European countries. Proportional Representation, or PR, would mean Devon County Council's councillors would look much more like the first chart and less like the second. 

Although there are concerns with using PR (such as it is harder to get an absolute majority) it does give a fairer share of elected officials to the electors, and it does force parties to work together to come up with solutions rather than minority voices having very little impact on decision making.

It also prevents people 'wasting their vote' as many voters feel their votes are pointless, especially in areas such as the South Hams with very large Conservative majorities, at district, county and national levels. 

It is a situation that plays out at a national level too, in the last General Election in 2019, the Conservative Party won a large 80-seat majority in the House of Commons with just 43.6% of the votes. 

 

The results are also interesting if you look at the votes for right- or left-leaning parties. We have added up the votes for the right-leaning parties (Conservative, Reform UK) and the left-leaning parties (Labour, Green, TUSC) and this is what happens: 

(I have put Lib Dems as Centrist and Freedom Alliance as 'Other', although you may disagree)

 

But the councillors elected look like this: 

So more people voted for centrist and left-leaning parties, but their county council is now overwhelmingly right-leaning. 

While this is not about one party more than another, it would seem fairer if the charts for votes cast looked more like the charts for seats gained. 

If, like me, you find all of this interesting (I know we're in the minority!), if not mildly annoying, you can find out more about proportional representation on the Make Votes Matter website HERE

 

User comments

There are no user comments for this listing.
Comments

You might also be interested in

Stoke Fleming road is now open
Category: General News
The road through Stoke Fleming is now open after exactly a month of diversions. 
Coroner releases cause of death for David 'Mad Dog' Crawford
Category: General News
Plymouth Coroner's office has released a statement about the cause of death for David Crawford, who died on the A38 in May. ...
Salcombe Regatta announces this year's royalty
Category: General News
Salcombe Town Regatta has released the official photos of the Regatta Royalty 2022. 
WINNERS! Four South Hams businesses are named the best in Devon at the Muddy Stilettos Awards 2022
Category: General News
Four South Hams businesses have won their Muddy Stilettos categories and been named the best in Devon.
New electric car charging points in Dartmouth "are a step on the road to net zero"
Category: General News
The first of 80 new Electric Vehicle (EV) charge points planned for 38 public car parks across Devon are now ready for public use...
Sculpture symbolising the pandemic lockdown has been unveiled in Totnes
Category: General News
A new sculpture symbolising the impact of the Covid pandemic and lockdowns has been unveiled in Totnes’ Lamb Garden.