Conservatives get less than half the votes but two-thirds of councillors in elections

SA Updated
Conservatives get less than half the votes but two-thirds of councillors in elections

The Conservative Party has taken two-thirds of the Devon County Council seats in the South Hams, despite winning less than half of the votes. 

We have had a look at the data that came out of the Devon County Council elections in the South Hams and the results are interesting, mainly due to our First Past The Post system of voting. 

In the South Hams, more people voted for parties other than the Conservative Party, and yet the Conservatives won four out of the seven seats. The Liberal Democrats won two with 24% and the Green party won one with nearly 14%. The Labour Party took 13% of the votes, but won no seats. 

 

Across the seven seats, the results were as follows:

Conservative -                          14,287 (46.8%)

Liberal Democrat -                      7,332 (24%)

Green -                                     4,180 (13.7%)

Labour -                                    3,922 (12.8%)

Freedom Alliance -                        648 (2.12%)

Reform UK -                                   92 (0.3%)

Trade Union and Socialist Coalition - 82 (0.27%)

 

This means that when the South Hams voted, it looked like this: 

But what we all got was this: 

This is due to the fact that in this country, we use the First Past the Post system, rather than Proportional Representation, which is used by 40/43 European countries. Proportional Representation, or PR, would mean Devon County Council's councillors would look much more like the first chart and less like the second. 

Although there are concerns with using PR (such as it is harder to get an absolute majority) it does give a fairer share of elected officials to the electors, and it does force parties to work together to come up with solutions rather than minority voices having very little impact on decision making.

It also prevents people 'wasting their vote' as many voters feel their votes are pointless, especially in areas such as the South Hams with very large Conservative majorities, at district, county and national levels. 

It is a situation that plays out at a national level too, in the last General Election in 2019, the Conservative Party won a large 80-seat majority in the House of Commons with just 43.6% of the votes. 

 

The results are also interesting if you look at the votes for right- or left-leaning parties. We have added up the votes for the right-leaning parties (Conservative, Reform UK) and the left-leaning parties (Labour, Green, TUSC) and this is what happens: 

(I have put Lib Dems as Centrist and Freedom Alliance as 'Other', although you may disagree)

 

But the councillors elected look like this: 

So more people voted for centrist and left-leaning parties, but their county council is now overwhelmingly right-leaning. 

While this is not about one party more than another, it would seem fairer if the charts for votes cast looked more like the charts for seats gained. 

If, like me, you find all of this interesting (I know we're in the minority!), if not mildly annoying, you can find out more about proportional representation on the Make Votes Matter website HERE

 

User comments

There are no user comments for this listing.
Comments

You might also be interested in

Devon and Cornwall "one of the safest places to live" according to latest police crime figures
Category: General News
According to the latest Office of National Statistics (ONS) crime figures, released recently, Devon and Cornwall remains one of the safest places to live...
Police appeal for dashcam footage after power cable theft
Category: General News
Devon and Cornwall Police are appealing for information from members of the public after another reported theft of copper from electricity lines near Ivybridge....
Footpath improves access to important outdoor space
Category: General News
A new footpath is encouraging even more use of South Brent Recreation Ground, according to the town’s recreation association.
Local photographer scoops silver in the WPE Awards finals
Category: General News
Kingsbridge based wedding and portrait photographer Martyn Norsworthy has kick-started the New Year with great news from the Wedding and Portrait Europe Awards (WPE)...
Two local fire crews attends fire at a block of flats in Plymouth
Category: General News
Two local fire crews attended a fire in a block of flats in Plymouth. 
SHDC are holding an open evening for prospective district councillors
Category: General News
Become a district councillor at South Hams and "make a difference for the future".

Featured Members

Luke Adams Lighting
 
0.0
 
5.0 (1)
We are a lighting company based in Kingsbridge, working in Salcombe, Dartmouth, Totnes, Plymouth...
Kingsbridge Auto Repair and Rescue Ltd
 
0.0 (0)
Kingsbridge Auto Repairs and Rescue Ltd - specialists in a wide range of garage...
Nigel Dalton Architectural Design Services
 
5.0 (1)
Nigel Dalton Architectural Design Services in the South West, Extensions, New Build, Commercial and...
Lilburn and Elliott Construction
 
0.0 (0)
Lilburn & Elliott Construction Ltd. New Builds, Extensions, Renovations, Alterations, Barn and Loft Conversions...
Staycation Eco Cleans
 
0.0 (0)
Offering a fully insured property management service for your holiday home or second home...
Pass the Keys - South Hams
 
0.0 (0)
Holiday Letting Agents and Airbnb co hosts based in Kingsbridge covering Salcombe, Kingsbridge, Dartmouth...
Form & Function Timberfaming
 
0.0 (0)
I am a friendly local craftsman with over 20 years experience. Although my...
Collaton Trailer Servicing - Blackawton, Totnes
 
0.0 (0)
Trailer Servicing and Trailer Repairs based in Blackawton covering Kingsbridge, Totnes, Dartmouth and surrounding...
Harris Law (South west) Ltd
 
5.0 (1)
Category: Human Resources HR
Tailored HR and Employment Law advice and support, Recruitment support, and HR training in...
Marvel Fitness
 
5.0 (1)
Marvel fitness is a small business offering boxing, open gym, personal training and more....
Chapman Contractors Ltd
 
0.0 (0)
Chapman Contractors Ltd specialise in gardening, landscaping, fencing, waste removal and plant hire in...
Churchstow MOT Centre
 
5.0 (1)
Churchstow MOT Centre is an established garage that offers vehicle servicing & MOT testing...
A P Goatman - Licensed Slaughterman - South Brent
 
4.8 (1)
Andrew Goatman is a dedicated and skilled licensed slaughterman, marksman and dart gun operator...
Couch Construction
 
0.0 (0)
Whether you are a home owner wishing to extend or refurbish your existing home,...
Avon Mill Garden centre
 
4.8 (3)
Avon Mill Garden Centre, Café & Shops - Independent Garden Centre in the Avon...
Bantham Village Stores and Coffee Terrace
 
5.0 (1)
Category: Cafes & Deli's
Visit us for delicious snacks, light lunches, coffee, other hot drinks, food and drink,...
Quay Wines - Kingsbridge
 
5.0 (1)
Category: Food & Drink
We are an independent wine merchant in Kingsbridge, South Hams. Formerly known as Luscombes...
The Bosko Bus - Gut Conscious Food Truck
 
5.0 (1)
Category: Takeaways
Gut conscious food truck based in Totnes and cover weddings and events all over...
Image Three Sixty - Commercial Property Images & Virtual Tours - Kingsbridge
 
0.0 (0)
A South Hams based company offering unique marketing solutions. Specialising in commercial property images,...
Martyn Norsworthy - Norsworthy Photography
 
0.0 (0)
Multi International Award Winning Portrait & Wedding Photographer, we offer you the very best...
Rendells
 
0.0 (0)
Rendells is an independent firm of Auctioneers, Valuers, Surveyors and Estate Agents, with offices...
Salcombe Paddle Boarding - Paddleboarding and Sea Kayaking Experiences
 
5.0 (2)
Salcombe Watersports - Stand Up Paddle Boarding - Sea Kayaking - Tuition - Estuary...
Sunrise Cottages
 
5.0 (1)
Sunrise Cottages aim to find you the best holiday accommodation to ensure you have...
Tellus Landscaping
 
0.0 (0)
A local environmentally friendly landscaping gardening company. Experienced gardeners offering garden design, wooden decking...
Actionwest Computer and IT Services
 
0.0 (0)
Actionwest Business Systems Ltd, Computer and Laptop Supply Servicing and IT Support for Home...
Pittman Trees - Tree Surgeons & Forestry Contractors
 
5.0 (5)
Pittman Trees are specialist tree surgery and forestry contractors working within the South Hams...
The Cottage Hotel - Hope Cove
 
5.0 (3)
The Cottage Hotel prides itself on being a traditional hotel, with old-fashioned service, comfortable...
Toad Hall Cottages - Holidays Lets and Property Management
 
3.1 (2)
Toad Hall Cottages is a family-run, award-winning company, letting holiday cottages and holiday homes...
Pollyanna Decorating
 
5.0 (7)
Pollyanna Decorating - Qualified and experienced, wall papering and general decorating - swift, professional,...
Coastal Living Property Management
 
0.0 (0)
EXCEPTIONAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT FOR YOUR HOLIDAY ACCOMMODATION IN THE SOUTH HAMS, SOUTH DEVON ...

Latest Listings

Latest Reviews

Bandstand set ablaze last night
RW Rob Wheeler
"A substantial reward is needed to bring these mindless vandals to account. They need taking off the streets, this serious..."
Carlys Decorating
 
5.0
JA John and Val
"Another great job Carly and Shannon. It was an absolute pleasure having you to decorate our living room. That's the..."
Merrifield House Devon
 
5.0
D Diana
"Lovely house in rural location. Spotlessly clean with very calm atmosphere. Outside sheltered area with tea and coffee making facilities..."
Simply Soulful Yoga & Therapies with Donna McCheyne
 
5.0
S S.L.
"Thoroughly enjoyed the SUP yoga class. Felt peaceful and more centred after it. Very relaxing listening to the sounds of..."
STG Engineering - Geotechnical Site Engineers
 
5.0
DH David Hickman
"Planning Authority deemed property to be within a Critical Drainage Area and requested a Surface Water Drainage Assessment and a..."
Liam Johns Carpentry
 
5.0
JS Jane Sandilands
"I am absolutely delighted with my Howdens kitchen, fitted by Liam. He did an excellent job and was polite, friendly..."
STG Engineering - Geotechnical Site Engineers
 
5.0
KB keith belt
"Contacted Simon after planners requested a drainage report. He came promptly was very professional and amiable. He managed to..."
SR Property Maintenance
 
5.0
RW Ross Wotton
"Highly recommend amazing customer service and amazing work. The jobs were done to a very high standard and great value..."
SHDC says waste service has seen "significant improvements" since it was taken in house
MT Martin Tyler
"What a load of rubbish. Nothing has changed as far as I am concerned. The problem over the..."
Man charged for "nonpayment" of parking charge, despite having proof
SH STEPHEN HEAL
"I had the same issued. Paid at the machine and could prove through my bank that I paid the..."
SHDC releases schedule for festive bin collections
DP Debbie Pickering
"Hi, can you update this to include your Monday collections please? 9th, 16th & 23rd?"
Simply Soulful Yoga & Therapies with Donna McCheyne
 
5.0
NF Nicola Felton
"Donna created an amazing and wonderful weekend for us all. Everything was thought of. Loved the outside space and the..."

Our Sponsors

* The information contained on this page is correct to the best of our knowledge, if you notice anything that you know to be incorrect or misleading, please contact us.

SouthHams.com Long Light logo

© 2012 - 2023 South Hams Online Ltd - All Rights Reserved. Legal & Privacy | Sitemap

built by FUTURECLIENT